Banding reviews — readiness and recommendations
The season overview, the readiness panel and how to preview a set of banding recommendations without changing anything.
The season overview
/Members is where an officer lands after signing in. Four tiles give the state of the season — teams registered, age groups, results outstanding, banding reviews due — followed by Needs your attention, which is the working list: age groups with no banding policy, reviews that are ready to run, and results never entered. Each carries a button straight to the page that resolves it.
Below that sit a per-age-group team count, four quick actions, and the banding readiness table — development age groups only, since only they band.
Reading the readiness table
| Column | Meaning |
|---|---|
| State | No policy, Not yet, Ready or Overdue. No policy means §12.3.1a has refused: the configuration is incomplete. Overdue appears only where the league stated a review interval. |
| Why | The reasoning in full — how many teams meet the evidence gates, how many sit above or below the competitiveness band, how many are in cooldown, and when the handover deadline falls. |
| Cycle | Which cycle of the season this age group is in. |
| Cooldown | How many teams have moved recently enough that they cannot move again yet. |
| Handover by | The date after which a review misses the next block of fixtures. Derived from the handover lead time in the policy. |
An age group with no policy still shows ratings and metrics. Only movement is blocked.
Previewing a review
/Members/Grading. Choose an age group and press Show readiness, then Preview recommendations.
The preview is a pure calculation. It writes no record, moves no team and notifies nobody — so it is safe to run as often as you like, including to check whether a policy change had the effect you expected.
Where it produces recommendations, each team gets a row: its current division, the recommendation, a confidence, its played count, win rate, close-game and heavy-result percentages, its rating with a deviation, and the checkpoint status. Beneath the table sits What a club is told — the plain-English rationale a club would receive for its own team, which states no rating and makes no comparison. The committee’s copy, which does state the rating, is behind a disclosure on each row.
Nothing moves automatically. The committee accepts, amends or rejects each suggestion and records a reason for any deviation, which is what makes the decision defensible to a club months later.
When a review refuses to generate
Two refusals are common, and they mean different things.
“Generation is refused for this age group.” The banding policy is incomplete. The page lists what is missing and links to the policy. This is a decision nobody has made, not data that has not arrived — no amount of football will resolve it.
“The review was not generated — only N of M teams meet the minimum-evidence gates.” The policy is complete but too little football has been played to meet it. This usually resolves itself as the season progresses; if it does not, the gates and the evidence window are contradicting each other and the policy needs revisiting.